A burn scar is scorched, bare ground with nothing growing on it. Pour a bucket of water on a lawn and much of it soaks into the soil. Pour it on a driveway and nearly all of it runs right off. A burn scar turns a whole hillside into, in essence, a driveway, because the fire has baked the ground hard and killed everything that used to soak up water…
So, the next storm or snowmelt sends everything the fire left behind—ash, soot, charred wood, dead vegetation, loose soil, and the burned remains of anything else that was in its path—sliding downhill into whatever river or reservoir sits below.
Colorado has watched burn-scar runoff hit the same river twice…
In July 2012, a month after the High Park Fire, heavy rain turned the Cache la Poudre River pitch black with soot and ash, and Fort Collins and Greeley both had to shut off their river intakes and use alternative sources for drinking water. Then the Cameron Peak Fire burned more than 200,000 acres of the same watershed in 2020, and the runoff from that burn scar hit the river the following summer. Greeley, which normally gets about 45% of its water from the Poudre, went about 40 days unable to treat river water at all.
The city's director of Water and Sewer Utilities called it “too black” and “too [full of] sediment” to bring in and treat. Customers in both cities never noticed, because their utilities had reservoirs to fall back on. Not every city has the same luxury.